The Anatomy of an Ideal Customer Success Manager
The Anatomy of an Ideal Customer Success Manager: Insights from 100 Industry Leaders
By: Mohammed Alqaq
Customer Success Management is evolving at an unprecedented pace, shaped by technological advancement, changing customer expectations, and the increasing complexity of business relationships.
I have asked more than 100 industry leaders over the last 2 years one question to describe the ideal CSM candidate. The responses reflect a diverse set of qualities that define the ideal CSM candidate. While the role varies depending on the company’s stage, industry, and customer base, there are several common themes that emerge across the responses. Their collective wisdom offers a compelling glimpse into the DNA of an exceptional CSM and provide valuable guidance for both aspiring CSMs and hiring managers in the field.
Table of Contents
Core Skills and Attributes
Communication and Emotional Intelligence
Many leaders, such as Rav Dhaliwal and Kate Neal, emphasize the importance of strong communication skills across various mediums. The ability to adapt communication styles based on the audience is critical. Additionally, high emotional intelligence (EQ) is frequently mentioned as essential, as CSMs must navigate customer relationships with empathy and tact.
Curiosity and a Growth Mindset
Leaders including Jay Nathan, Marija Skobe-Pilley, and Barry Murphy highlight curiosity as a key trait. A great CSM is always learning—about their customers, their industry, and their own product. Growth-minded individuals who seek continuous improvement are well-suited for the role.
Problem-Solving and Critical Thinking
Many responses, such as those from Funmilayo Ojeleye and Jyo Shukla, stress the importance of problem-solving. CSMs need to approach challenges with creativity and resourcefulness rather than merely escalating issues to other teams.
Empathy and Customer-Centricity
Empathy is a recurring theme in responses from leaders like Irina Vatafu and Stella Ikhnana. Successful CSMs genuinely care about customer success and work to understand their challenges. Being customer-obsessed and anticipating needs before they arise is a valuable skill.
Ownership and Accountability
Leaders such as Hakan Ozturk and Carmel Granahan emphasize the need for CSMs to take ownership of their accounts. A great CSM treats their portfolio like their own business, ensuring follow-ups and delivering on promises.
Strategic Thinking and Business Acumen
Many contributors, such as Peter Armaly and Sofia Kiriukhina, highlight the importance of understanding business objectives and aligning customer goals with company success. CSMs should be proactive in identifying opportunities for growth and renewal.
Adaptability and Resilience
Leaders like Sue Nabeth Moore and Jan Young discuss the ever-changing nature of the CS role. CSMs must be flexible, embracing new challenges and evolving with the company’s needs.
“You can focus on adoption, retention, expansion, or advocacy; or you can focus on the customers' Desired Outcome and get all of those things”
Specialized Skills and Perspectives
Beyond the fundamental skills, some leaders pointed out additional qualities depending on company needs:
Technical Proficiency: Leaders like Stuart Scott and Joe Di Grande mention that strong technical understanding, particularly in SaaS and B2B environments, is beneficial for troubleshooting and adding value.
Data-Driven Mindset: Brittany Casey and Parul Bhandari highlight the importance of using data to inform customer interactions, whether through health scores, performance metrics, or expansion strategies.
Collaboration and Cross-Functional Influence: Olivier Fiaty and Rovi Oblea emphasize the need for teamwork across departments such as sales, product, and engineering.
Negotiation and Sales Acumen: Several leaders, including Cara Benecke and Tom Carnewal, note that modern CSMs need some level of sales and negotiation skills, especially as CS increasingly impacts revenue.
“Once the ink dries on the contract, the Customer Success team is there to take them from “I hope this works” to “Wow, this really works!”
Comparison of Responses
While the ideal CSM profile shares many commonalities, there are notable differences in emphasis:
Traditional vs. Modern CSM Expectations: Some responses, like those from Brittany Casey and Rosana Greco, highlight a shift toward revenue-driven CS, requiring sales-oriented skills. Others, such as Emma Hunter and Shirley Chapman, advocate for a customer-first approach, warning against rigid playbooks.
Experience vs. Mindset: Leaders like Nabeeda Bakali and Rafael Escano stress that there is no single background for CSMs. Instead, traits like curiosity, problem-solving, and adaptability matter more than prior CS experience.
Soft Skills vs. Technical Expertise: Some leaders, such as Irina Vatafu, argue that soft skills like empathy and communication are more important than technical skills. Others, like Jean-Francois Tetreault, suggest that technical knowledge can differentiate a great CSM in SaaS.
Diversity of Thought: Leaders like Marco Carrubba advocate for hiring diverse candidates who bring unique perspectives, rather than searching for a standardized CSM profile.
The responses confirm that an ideal CSM candidate is not defined by a rigid skillset but by a combination of soft skills, adaptability, and customer focus. While communication, empathy, and problem-solving are universally valued, the precise mix of skills depends on company needs. Some organizations prioritize technical expertise and data analysis, while others focus on relationship-building and emotional intelligence.
Ultimately, a great CSM is one who balances customer advocacy with business objectives, continuously learns and grows, and takes ownership of their customer relationships. As the CS field evolves, these qualities will remain essential for driving customer success and business growth.
Author
Mohammed Alqaq
The Founder of Customer Success Middle. 2024 Top 25 Customer Success Influencer, 2023 Top 100 Customer Success Strategists,’ and was nominated as one of the ‘Most Creative Customer Success Leaders in 2023 & 2024.’ These recognition's represent not only personal milestones but also a testament to his dedication to redefining customer success. His journey in this field is not just about achieving results, but also about creating meaningful, long-lasting experiences that drive business growth.
Stay ahead of the game.
Sign up to the newsletter.
Get all the hottest customer success conversations and talking points landing in your inbox once a month, every month.
